top of page

Navigating Unfair Dismissal: Key Insights from Orry Thompson v Zadlea Pty Ltd T/A Atlas Steel [2019] FWC 168

In the ever-evolving landscape of employment law, the Orry Thompson case against Zadlea Pty Ltd, trading as Atlas Steel, provides a profound examination of the principles of unfair dismissal, procedural fairness, and natural justice. This landmark case, adjudicated by the Fair Work Commission (FWC), underscores the necessity of adherence to these principles in the workplace. Let's explore the intricacies of this case and its implications for both employers and employees.

Background of the Case

Orry Thompson faced an unfair dismissal from his position at Atlas Steel and challenged this decision, citing that the dismissal was unjust, harsh, and unreasonable. His claim led to an important FWC ruling that not only addressed his case but also set significant precedents regarding procedural fairness and natural justice in cases of unfair dismissal.

Navigating Unfair Dismissal: Key Insights from Orry Thompson v Zadlea Pty Ltd T/A Atlas Steel [2019] FWC 168
Navigating Unfair Dismissal: Key Insights from Orry Thompson v Zadlea Pty Ltd T/A Atlas Steel [2019] FWC 168

Procedural Fairness and Natural Justice

Procedural Fairness: Central to the FWC's findings was the lack of procedural fairness in Thompson's dismissal. The employer failed seven times to provide Thompson with an opportunity to respond to the allegations of misconduct. This lack of procedural fairness was a decisive factor in ruling the dismissal as unfair.

Natural Justice: The principles of natural justice were significantly breached in this case. Twelve times the decision highlighted how the employer did not adequately allow Thompson to defend himself or challenge the evidence against him. These violations of natural justice were crucial in deeming the dismissal to be unfair.

The Severity of Misconduct and Unfair Dismissal

The FWC meticulously examined whether Thompson's alleged misconduct warranted an unfair dismissal. It concluded that the actions, while inappropriate, did not meet the threshold of seriousness that would justify such a dismissal without recourse. This finding was pivotal, illustrating how assessments of misconduct must align with the standards of natural justice to avoid unfair dismissal.

Consistency in Handling Unfair Dismissal

The consistency of disciplinary actions within a company influences perceptions of procedural fairness and natural justice. The FWC noted inconsistencies in how similar past incidents were handled by the employer, which contributed to the ruling of unfair dismissal. This aspect of the case serves as a reminder of the importance of uniform application of disciplinary policies to uphold natural justice and avoid claims of unfair dismissal.

The Impact of Unfair Dismissal

The personal and economic impacts of Thompson’s unfair dismissal were significant. The FWC considered these effects extensively, underlining that decisions leading to unfair dismissal must take into account the broader consequences on an employee's life, reinforcing the principles of natural justice and procedural fairness.

Conclusion and Implications

The FWC's decision to reinstate Thompson was a clear directive on the importance of procedural fairness and adherence to natural justice in preventing unfair dismissals. This case serves as a crucial reminder for all employers:

- Uphold Procedural Fairness: Ensure that all employees are given a fair chance to respond to allegations, maintaining procedural fairness.

- Adhere to Natural Justice: Respect the elements of natural justice by allowing employees to contest evidence and providing a fair hearing, which are fundamental to preventing unfair dismissals.

- Consistency Is Key: Apply disciplinary actions consistently to support the principles of natural justice and procedural fairness, thereby reducing the risk of unfair dismissals.

- Consider the Broader Impact: Recognize that the repercussions of unfair dismissal extend beyond the workplace and can profoundly affect an individual's life.

Through understanding and implementing these principles, workplaces can foster a fair, just, and equitable environment. For further insights into maintaining fairness and justice in employment practices, continue to follow our updates here at

28 views0 comments


bottom of page